David Hilsenrad
The Fish House | 1310 Winter Ave. | 502.568.2993
(This story originally appeared in the Summer 2021 print issue.)
Moving to the Head of the Line
Twenty-two centuries ago, when the Greek mathematician Archimedes was figuring out how to calculate the surface area and volume of cylinders and spheres, he began by postulating that a straight line is the shortest distance between two points.
I postulate that Archimedes never visited the Fish House/Café Beignet on a Friday night during Lent (or, in fact, many nights throughout the year), when the restaurant is packed beyond its proverbial gills. Because on those nights, the Fish House queue, no matter how straight, is the longest distance between a hungry appetite and fried perfection.
The Fish House/Café Beignet line is arguably the cheeriest line in the city, a fact that may confound first-timers accustomed to the sighs and frowns that are typical in longish queues. This line is invariably patient, even on the occasions when it wends its way onto the patio, as it did during much of the pandemic, after the restaurant marked out six-foot
spacing intervals. Most times, the line coalesces into a happy ad hoc community of strangers united in a common cause.
The Fish House Restaurant
If you look to the head of the line, about 99% of the time you will see either David Hilsenrad (who founded Fish House in 1993) or his son Adam, (who founded Café Beignet in 2001).
David and Adam greet a high percentage of customers by name — an indication they have a lot of repeat customers. If you’re waiting to collect a to-go order as you linger near the register, you’ll overhear a congenial stream of conversation that touches on pretty much everything: Louisville gossip, horse racing, developments in the restaurant scene, family anecdotes, and music (David Hilsenrad played trumpet in the 52nd United States Army Band).
While you’re waiting, take a look around at the award plaques and the bric-a-brac on the walls and counters. Ask David or Ad …


















